Showing posts with label CrashCover. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CrashCover. Show all posts

Saturday, August 7, 2021

"330 is going down", an explosion in mid air

In an episode of Exploring Stamps, Graham spoke of my crash cover and I thought it would be nice to give more information than the cold facts, after all people lost their lives.

February 21, 1970, a cold and wet Saturday, Switzerland was shaken when Swissair 330 bound for Tel Aviv, crashed shortly after take-off from Zurich. Swissair Flight 330 was a regularly scheduled flight from Zurich International Airport in Kloten, Switzerland, to Hong Kong with a planned stopover in Tel Aviv, Israel.

About nine minutes after take-off, during the ascent on a southerly course, a bomb detonated in the aft cargo compartment of the aircraft. The bomb was triggered by a change in atmospheric pressure. The crew desperately tried to turn the plane around and attempt an emergency landing at Zürich but had difficulty seeing the instruments due to smoke in the cockpit. The aircraft deviated more and more to the west. “330 is going down,” co-pilot Armand Etienne told the control tower in German and added “Goodbye everybody” in English. The flight crashed a short time later due to a loss of power, killing everyone on board: 38 passengers and nine crew.

Let us look for a moment at the co pilot Armand Etienne. He was actually born in Odessa, Russia in 1918, but his family came from Lausanne, Switzerland. Armand moved to Australia and joined the RAAF in 1939 when war broke out.

Completing his training he was then assigned to a Squadron operating American-built PB-Y "Catalina" Flying-Boats. One of his fellow crews was forced into the sea, and he promptly set out on a rescue mission to pick them up. He took off to fly the mission in broad daylight, and after flying low over Japanese-held territory, he soon located his stranded comrades, and then safely brought them home. For this remarkable rescue under the eyes of the Japanese, he was decorated for his outstanding courage and grim determination with the Distinguished Flying Cross (D.F.C.).

He joined Swissair in 1953. Armand is often referred to as a Captain but on the fateful flight 330, he was the co-pilot. RIP and thank you for your service.

Continuing with our story, the PFLP-GC (Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine-General Command) initially claimed responsibility out of their HQ in Beirut Lebanon, but they retracted it after a few days. One possible motive was revenge against Switzerland for three Palestinians who had been sentenced to 12 years imprisonment by a Swiss court.

The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine-General Command (PFLP-GC) was established in April 1968 by Ahmed Jibril. Jibril recently passed away, July 7th. At the time, being of Syrian descent, he was a member of the PFLP, the PLO, and a captain in the Syrian Army. He wanted to focus more on terrorism and less on politics. The PFLP-GC is not to be confused with PFLP of George Habash. Monty Python "Life of Brian" anyone? 


A black instructional marking in French was applied to any mail which translated reads:
Correspondence is from "Coronado" that fell at Würenlingen. Zürich 58 Post Office

Now here we have an interesting side to the story. Within a few days the main suspect was named as a Jordanian who had intended of blowing up an Israeli plane. As a result of a flight diversion, it ended up on a Swissair plane. Yet no suspects were ever taken to court, despite arrest warrants, and despite this being defined as the worst terrorist attack in Swiss history. The Swiss investigator handed his report to the federal attorney-general but complained later that the Swiss authorities seemed to throw a “cloak of silence” over the case.

In September of the same year, a Swissair flight which was on its way to New York, was hijacked and ended up at Dawson's Field, a disused airstrip in Jordanian desert.

In 2016, the Neue Zürcher Zeitung (NZZ) newspaper reported that, while Switzerland was desperately trying to get negotiate to get their hostages released, Swiss Foreign Minister Pierre Graber allegedly secretly contacted the PLO. Using a member of the Swiss parliament as an intermediary, but without informing his fellow government ministers, apparently Graber had come to an agreement under which those charged for the attack on the Swissair plane would be released in return for freeing the hostages. The allegations emerged in a book entitled, “Swiss Terror Years."

In addition the investigation into the bombing of the Swissair flight would be quietly shelved, no wonder no one was charged and everything was hushed up. Switzerland also agreed to use its diplomatic offices to push for international recognition of the PLO. 

The agreement was apparently designed to prevent terrorist attacks on Swiss territory. Strangely Reuters reported that apparently a Swiss investigation found no evidence that a government minister struck a secret deal with the Palestine Liberation Organization. In my opinion, there must have been something as there were no more terror attacks in Switzerland. This does show that terror works.

The Swissair bombing also had an understandable effect on mail including letters and parcels. After the bombing many international carriers suspended mail and cargo services to Israel, claiming that the measure was temporary. One captain of a Swissair flight refused to take outgoing mail, of course he was scared, but agreed when he was informed that he was acting contrary to his company's instructions.

Of course Israel approached the International Postal Union to act against any delays in foreign mail deliveries but this did not help. As a result mail sent or routed to Israel through the UK, Italy, and the USA was required to be sent only by surface mail in the immediate future. Airmail to Israel was no longer permitted.



Hebrew inscription "Arrived via surface mail" via the sea

Once again terrorism wins the day. Check out my blog about the Munich massacre at the Olympics.


Print Friendly and PDF

Friday, June 4, 2021

A cold war incident

In a previous blog post, we learned that of all the countries in the world, only Czechoslovakia was selling arms to Israel and only because mother Russia, or Big Daddy, allowed them to.

Now Mommy Russia was not doing it out of the goodness of her heart, oh no, who would do that? Russia was one of the countries that immediately recognized the new state of Israel, albeit three days later. Maybe it took the email three days to arrive.

So why? Well the Cold War between the west and the east had begun in 1947 and tensions were high. The cold war actually started in 1947 with what was called the Truman Doctrine. The Americans did not want Russia to spread communism around the globe, they wanted to spread democracy instead. Good luck with democracy in Islamic countries, but that is another issue.

Many of the big boys in the Jewish State had origins in the eastern bloc. Many even spoke Russian. OK they also spoke English, German, Yiddish, French and nonsense, but since when is that relevant. So the Russians naturally thought that Israel would become a Russian satellite. Who knows they may even become a communist country.

America, on the other hand, did not trust the Jewish State for the same reason and placed an arms embargo. Actually POTUS called David Ben Gurion just before the declaration and begged him not to declare independence. The American Secretary of State George Marshall did not believe that the Jewish State would survive the war and did not want to support it. WW2 had just ended. He also did not want to loose the Arab countries. Logical after all, they had more money and were huge.

England did not want Israel not as a Jewish State and not as anything and some of their Spitfire jets attacked Israel. Some of their soldiers were actually caught as prisoners of war. Their ships still patrolled the port of Haifa after the Mandate ended and one of their generals, Glubb Pasha, was in charge of the Jordanian Legion.

But after the war, Israel did not become a satellite of Russia, nor did it buy arms from them. They bought from France. However Israel was not really on either side, the new kid just wanted to survive. Can't really blame her, right? She was faced with belligerency on all sides and constantly attacked and the world did nothing. Wait are we talking about 2021 or 1950?

Now tensions between East and West are high and the west had created the NATO defense pact. In May 1955, the Soviet Union and her satellites created their own defense pact, the Warsaw Pact. Bulgaria was one of the countries which was a part of that pact and there begins our story of the day.

EL AL, Israel's state airline, which was once jokingly referred to as Every Landing Always Late, was on a routine flight from London to Tel Aviv on the evening of Tuesday, July 26, 1955. It departed Heathrow Airport en route to Lod (today Ben-Gurion International Airport), via Vienna and and then Istanbul. After a brief layover at the Austrian capital, the Lockheed Constellation – a four-engine propeller plane – took off for Istanbul shortly before 3 A.M. on July 27.

Soon after takeoff, the flight encountered a thunderstorm, something that was known to cause distortions in the old-fashioned NDR navigation system in use in those days. In the case of LY-402, which was flying along the “Amber 10” air lane, it appears that the pilot changed course after concluding incorrectly that he had passed over the Skopje (Macedonia) navigation beacon. This change of direction caused the aircraft to cross from Yugoslavia into Bulgaria, near the border village of Tran.

Detecting the violation of its airspace, the Bulgarian air force scrambled two MiG-15 “Fagot” jet fighters from the Dobroslavtsi airfield to intercept the intruder. The plane flew over Bulgaria for 200km with the two Bulgarian jets trailing it for most of that distance, and at the time the pilots claimed to have issued several warning shots, but this claim was soon retracted. According to a history of Bulgarian aviation, the deputy commander of Bulgarian air defense, Gen. Velitchko Georgiev, told the two pilots, “If the plane is leaving our territory, disobeying orders, and there is no time left for more warnings, then shoot it down.”

What’s clear is that, as the civilian plane neared the country’s southern border and was about to cross into Greek airspace, the MiGs fired at it. The Constellation exploded at an altitude of 2,000 feet, with its pieces falling to earth near Petrich, Bulgaria. 51 passengers and seven crew members were killed.


The cover depicted above survived the crash. There is a Hebrew violet cancel: "This letter survived the EL AL flight that was brought down in Bulgaria, 27/7/55"

What happened and why? There was speculation that the Constellation plane was being used by the American Air Force for intelligence activities and was involved in espionage on Bulgaria and they didn't want the plane to leave Bulgarian air space. In fact, the plane that was used by EL AL was the same type as the American intelligence gathering plane.

One researcher concluded that “The Bulgarians wanted to demonstrate to the Soviets their power and their ability to control their airspace, to prove their loyalty and that they were worthy of the mission and purpose that had been delegated to them”.

Although the Bulgarian government at first refused to accept responsibility, blaming the Israeli airliner for penetrating its airspace without authorization, it eventually issued a formal apology, stating that the fighter pilots had been “too hasty” in shooting down the airliner, and agreed to pay compensation to the victims’ families. The compensation amount was a joke, each of the families of the victims received $8,236 which corresponded to the maximum compensation payment fixed by the Warsaw Convention for damage claims of individuals against foreign governments. 

Print Friendly and PDF

Tuesday, January 12, 2021

Kalamata Incident

We all know there was a war for Israel’s basic existence in 1948 and if you didn’t, sorry about that. At that time, there was a worldwide boycott of arms sales to Israel except for one country, Czechoslovakia. Whoever thinks that the Americans stood by us at this time, is wrong, this is a pretty common mistake nowadays that is heard mostly on social media.

Why did countries not want to sell us weapons? Good question, and I don’t have many answers only that Western countries did not want to annoy their Arab customers, after all we are a small country compared to the many large countries surrounding us that also had oil. An old joke says that it is a pity that Moshe, our ancestor from the Bible should have turned left instead of right. If he had turned right we would have the oil and the Arabs oranges, referring to Jaffa oranges. Of course it is an old joke, because Jaffa oranges are not what they once were, if there is such a thing today.


Czechoslovakia was willing, but only with Russia's approval, since in 1948 they were a part of the Russian Alliance. And why were they willing, other than to receive money like Pfizer nowadays? 😊 

Well Jan Masaryk, the then Czech Foreign Minister, was a friend of Israel and allowed the sale of weaponry. For those who don’t know, Kfar Masaryk is named after his father. 

The weaponry we received was the same weapons that they produced for the Nazis. We had soldiers who had previously served in the British Army but who knew how to use German equipment? We also bought planes from them but who knew how to fly a Messerschmitt plane, like the one in the Cuban stamp pictured above? It turns out that no one, and Ezer Weizmann, who was a pilot in the British Air Force during World War Two, knew the British Spitfire plane very well, flew to Czechoslovakia to learn about the Messerschmitt.

Flights from Czechoslovakia to Israel brought small arms and of course mail. There was a war going on, so which flights would bring mail? For some unknown reason they had no emails in 1948, I do not know why. Among the Czech pilots who flew regularly to Israel, was a brave man named Vaclav Fogler.

Fogler wanted to defect to the West and had an exact plan, unlike our government’s, but success depended on him returning to Prague on December 24th (Christmas Eve, when security would be lax) and smuggling his family out. He had to adhere to the strict schedule of leaving Rome on December 21st, flying to Athens, then Lydda (Lod), near Tel Aviv, and back again, a very tight schedule. A round trip in three days, on a Dakota plane? It may sound ridiculous today, because a flight to the Czech Republic is only a few hours, but who wants to go to Prague in the winter?

Nothing happens in a vacuum and in December 1948, something is going on in Greece that could greatly affect Fogler's plan but no one told him about it. Since the liberation of Greece from Nazi occupation, Greek Communist partisans had tried to overthrow the pro-Western government by an open revolt, similar to my previous story, no? England and the United States supported the Greek government and England also served as de facto ruler of Greece during 1948, not exactly an occupation. So on December 21st, 1948, the day Folger left Rome, fierce fighting took place all over Greece, between the government and the rebels. It is important for you to know that the rebels were receiving constant air drops from the Yugoslav Air Force.

British intelligence commanded air traffic control in Greece, including Athens and the airport of Kalamata, a city in southern Greece, and wanted to identify each and every flight before assisting in takeoff and landing, and of course they did not give permits to the Yugoslav Air Force.

When Fogler approached Greece carrying weapons for the IDF, bad weather forced him to deviate from the original flight plan and he radioed this to Athens. There was total darkness and he had no idea where he was and he was unable to identify his whereabouts, He asked for help from the nearest air traffic control to help him identify his whereabouts. He broadcast again and again, and was met with total radio silence. He had no idea that his SOS was actually heard in London, Malta and Tangier he did not know that Greece's air control did not answer intentionally. And why? Because British intelligence believed that the intention of the Czech flight was to drop weapons to the local Communist rebels. Kalamata Airport was less than 60 km away and could easily have handled the Dakota, but the British forced air control not to respond.

The partisans heard the plane in the sky above them and of course assumed that the flight was intended for them. They hurried to turn on lights and other marks on a ridge, suitable for dropping supplies. Poor Fogler thought that the equipment on his plane was not working properly because of the radio silence and was delighted to see the lights. He believed that they were showing a runway that would be suitable for an emergency landing. As he began landing, he suddenly noticed a hill. Unable to climb in time, he collided with the ridge. The Czech airliner crashed near Kalamata, Greece on December 21, 1948.

Of course the partisans pounced on the plane, stole all our weapons and left us with nothing but a few letters that survived the crash. Too bad we did not have insurance. In addition to the pilot, there were other unfortunate passengers on the plane, including fourteen Israelis.

If you had received a letter like the one below, torn, tatty, burned and dirty, wouldn’t you have thrown it in the trash? No? I have not seen many letters that survived this crash and they are of course quite rare but of course they exist. No one knows exactly how many survived. The example below is from my personal collection. The story is based on an article in issue 36 of the journal HLPH.

Print Friendly and PDF

Statcounter